[wix-devs] Strange RichEdit behavior in Burn with Turkish keyboard

Bob Arnson bob at firegiant.com
Fri Jul 6 17:42:26 PDT 2018

Please file an issue at http://wixtoolset.org/bugs/ so it shows up at our next triage meeting.

-----Original Message-----
From: wix-devs <wix-devs-bounces at lists.wixtoolset.org> On Behalf Of Denis Z. via wix-devs
Sent: Thursday, 5 July, 2018 09:16
To: wix-devs at lists.wixtoolset.org
Cc: Denis Z. <denis.gz at gmail.com>
Subject: [wix-devs] Strange RichEdit behavior in Burn with Turkish keyboard

Hi all!

As was reported by our support team of the product which I maintain Burn-based installer for, there's a strange issue (fix is ready - see
below) when installer is run on a system with Turkish language installed.
This is reproduced easily (at least on Windows 7, but the effect is most obvious on Windows 10):

0. Prerequisites: Have some Burn based installer, configured to use standard WixStdBA module with RtfLargeLicense theme. For example, vcredist_x86.exe from MSVC2015 will do.
1. Install Turkish language in the system, along with Turkish keyboard layout (e.g. TRQ) 2. Open CMD console, switch to TRQ layout (or just run from Desktop with TRQ layout active) 3. Run the installer you prepared 4. Quit installer, either cancel or let it run to the end 5. Notice the active keyboard layout, on step 3 and step 4

Expected result: Active keyboard layout doesn't change (so it still should be TRQ on step 3 and 4).
Actual result: Active keyboard layout changes to the previous one before TRQ was set (e.g. ENG).

The strange thing is this is only happening with Turkish layouts. Spanish, German, Russian, etc. does not show such behavior with Burn.

As I was able to investigate, the bug concluded in RichEdit control which is used in RtfLargeLicense theme. For some reason, the code inside RICHED20.DLL calls ActivateKeyboardLayout with different layout than currently selected. Previously GetKeyState with VK_SHIFT argument reports incorrect state for Shift key(s), so may be this triggers the bug (this doesn't happen with other layouts).

So while all this doesn't relate to Burn code, there's an easy fix possible
- just use MSFTEDIT_CLASS when you create RichEdit control (the newer one), instead of RICHEDIT_CLASS which is used currently (old code). This change also implies changing the library to load - now it's MSFTEDIT.DLL, instead of RICHED20.DLL. This library exists at least on Windows XP SP3 (cannot check older SP) and later versions, and works perfectly as a drop-in replacement. Probably other issues could be fixed as well, if any (on Win10, this is of version 3.1 vs. version 8.5 of MSFTEDIT).

On order to deploy this fix, it is only necessary to change a couple of lines in thmutil.cpp (around "case THEME_CONTROL_TYPE_RICHEDIT:") and PrintEula.cpp (similar lines, for MSI-based UI) and rebuild WixStdBA.dll.
Now replace <BootstrapperApplicationRef> element with <BootstrapperApplication>, add (now missing) <PayloadGroupRef Id='WixStdbaRtfLargeLicensePayloads' /> to the content, as well as existing <bal:WixStandardBootstrapperApplication/> and you are done.

Hope this fix will be included in later WiX builds.

Best regards,
WiX Toolset Developer Mailing List provided by FireGiant http://www.firegiant.com/

More information about the wix-devs mailing list